Trophies disappear when I remove them from top shelf
I got a new trophy and went to rearrange them so I could display it but when I moved a trophy off of the shelf it disappeared. This happens with trophies before the wipe (which I still have) and new trophies.
Ok, I see this happening. But when you reopen the trophy case, the trophy should be there, and the empty spot still on top where you took it. Can you confirm this? That is what happened when I tried it out of a few of mine.