I'm still doing this! accidentally feeding all my allspice to pigs. it's SO annoying.
Earlier on I had some Abbasid Ribs, and I fed those to a pig instead, since alphabetically they are first on the list.
I can see that changing the whole menu structure would be too much for a small problem like this, but wouldn't it be great if there was an item that came first that you didn't mind feeding to your pigs? like Air? or Aair. Something that was maybe a bit of a pain to replace, but not as bad as ALL your allspice.....